The Glitch & The Fix

Preventing Short Cycling

The Glitch

The Glitch

Overview: An installer is advised to use a buffer tank to prevent short cycling of a low mass boiler serving several independently controlled space heating zones. The system also needs to provide domestic hot water. The design he comes up with is shown below.

Exercise: Find at least five errors in this layout.

The Fix

The Fix

One rule of working with buffer tanks is to not operate the buffer tank as part of the domestic water heating mode. The indirect tank provides plenty of thermal mass to stabilized the boiler during this mode. Storing heat in buffer tank for domestic water heating only adds to standby heat loss. The fix is to operate the indirect tank as a separate circuit independent of the space heating loads. Notice that hot water from the boiler is drawn through the air separator in either space heating or DHW mode.

The series primary/secondary piping shown in the Glitch lowers the supply water temperature to the downstream secondary circuits. If the DHW tank was allowed to operate simultaneously with space heating, the heat exchanger in the indirect tank would get a relatively low supply temperature due to temperature drop across the space heating secondary circuits. Better to pipe these secondary circuits as parallel circuit to give them the same supply temperature.

The incorrect piping also allows an undetermined percentage of the boiler flow to pass through the buffer tank rather than pass through the primary loop. This could exasperate the problem of temperature drop along the primary loop due to low flow.

Finally, if the boiler is off and heat is being supplied from the buffer tank, there is no way to prevent hot water flow through the boiler heat exchanger. This situation will lead to excessive heat loss from the boiler jacket.

In the Fix drawing, the buffer tank is simply piped in as an alternative heat source. When its secondary circulator is operating, its thermal mass “participates” in the space heat operation. If there is any space heating mode where the buffer tank is not needed, it can be taken offline by turning off its circulator.


1. Buffer tank charging mode: Circulators P2 and P3 are operating and boiler is firing. If zone circulators are off then flow make "U-turn" between closely spaced tees A and B. If one or more zones are on entering flow "splits" at tee A (some to load, remainder to buffer tank through tee B.

2. Supplying zones from boiler only: P2 is on, P3 is off. Hot water from boiler is injected at tee A, and drawn through zones. Return water is pulled out at B and returned to boiler.

3. Supplying zones from buffer tank only: If buffer tank is hot enough, and there is a call for space heating. P2 is off, P3 is on. Hot water enter distribution system at tee A and returns to buffer tank from tee B.

4. Prioritized domestic water heating: Circualtor P1 is on, P2 is off. P3 might be operating if space heating zones are active.  


Did you enjoy this article? Click here to subscribe to receive Radiant and Hydronics eNewsletter twice a month, delivered right to your inbox. 

Recent Articles by John Siegenthaler, P.E.

You must login or register in order to post a comment.



Image Galleries

2013 QSC Power Meeting XXXVIII

March 14-16, 2013, San Diego

Photos by Kelly Faloon/Plumbing & Mechanical

8/26/14 1:00 pm EST

Free Webinar: Low Temperature Heat Emitter Options in Hydronic Systems

With proper design, you can create systems that require supply water temperatures no higher than 120° F under design load conditions.

Radiant and Hydronics eNews

august cover

2013 August

In the August edition of Radiant & Hydronics, read about new technology in measuring energy, NASCAR driver Ryan Newman and State Water Heaters new partnership and Bradford White's newest apps. Also check out the latest products in the heating and cooling industry.

Table Of Contents Subscribe

Where do you look for new employees?

Where do you look for new employees?
View Results Poll Archive

The Radiant and Hydronics Store

M:\General Shared\__AEC Store Katie Z\AEC Store\Images\radiant hydronics\HydronicsKnowHowII_CD.gif
Hydronics Know How II CD

The Hydronics Know How II CD contains all the columns and articles John Siegenthaler has written for Plumbing & Mechanical and PM Engineer, from the very first in July 1996 through December 2008. That’s over 200 articles and columns covering everything from heat loss to hydraulic separation.

More Products

Clear Seas Research

Clear Seas ResearchWith access to over one million professionals and more than 60 industry-specific publications, Clear Seas Research offers relevant insights from those who know your industry best. Let us customize a market research solution that exceeds your marketing goals.


Facebook logo Twitter logo    YouTube logo      linkedin_40px.png

Radiant Flooring Guide

Radiant flooring guide 2013Your Guide to suitable floor coverings and submaterials for use with radiant heating. CLICK HERE to read the latest edition of Radiant Floring Guide.